Husband and I went to Schmaltz Appetizing on Saturday and quite enjoyed the experience. It's a cozy little spot on ossington and Dundas. It's made to look like an old school pharmacy, but don't let it fool you - you'll see the sign for Schmalz at the top in blue.
Service was slow, but they were busy and it is the ossington strip so we knew we'd have to wait. The bagels and our coffee came out relatively quickly.
Bagels are good. Not NYC good but good. Our bagels and two coffees were about $27.