Native New Yorker gets a 3 merely because I really like their wings, other than that I could really do without this place in any sort of eating rotation.
Their menu is huge and often leaves you spending time struggling between choices, but there is nothing that spectacular about anything on it. I have tried sandwiches, pizza, pizza puffs, appetizers and all are just OK. It is standard bar fare but without anything special to push it over the edge. The service is hit or miss depending on the day.