I always believe in second chances so I thought it only fair to revisit my review of The Old Fashioned. Here is my original review;
My Fiance and I tried The Old Fashioned about two months ago. We ordered the Wisconsin's Best Wurst platter, but I can't tell you how it was because we never got it, I'm pretty positive our server forgot because it didn't show up on our bill. For dinner, I had the Prime Rib Saturday night special, which was pretty bland, and my fiance had a sandwich which he said wasn't anything out of the ordinary. The drinks were strong which is the only reason The Old Fashioned got two stars instead of one in my book, probably won't be going back for food, but maybe drinks.
Updated Review:
We've been back a few times since our original visit and I have to say it has gotten better. I'm chalking up my first review to meh, lets say off service. I used to be a server so I can understand an off day. Anyways, since then I have had a few drinks at The Old Fashioned. My favorites are Side cars, Old Fashioned. and Amaretto Sours. Each time I have gotten a pretty darn good drink with equally good service. I've only eaten the cheese curds and a burger (can't remember the name) but they were quite good as well. I'm becoming a life longer member or anything but I don't mind occasionally stopping in for a drink or two!