Just went here yesterday on a whim and it was one of the best lunches I've had in years. I was looking for something fresh and healthy and considered going to Live down the street but thought I'd try something new. I'm so glad I did.
I had the Madison Sandwich and the Curried Carrot and Ginger Soup and oh my, both were incredible. The grilled chicken in the sandwich was incredibly moist and well seasoned. And they do not skimp on the chicken at all. The soup was very hearty and garnished with cilantro, which I love (though she did ask me if I wanted some. I know cilantro can be a polarizing herb so this was just one example of the great customer service).
The woman serving me, who I've learned was the proprietor was incredibly friendly and helpful and made me feel welcome in what is a very intimate space.
The soup and sandwich cookie with a "flourless cashew cookie" from Sweets of the Earth (which was also very tasty) came out to just under $15. So not super cheap but great value for fresh ingredients!