Came here with my hubby after hearing some pretty good comments about the restaurant, so I was naturally excited to try out a local Italian place.
The ambiance was nice, staff were friendly but it took longer than expected to get a glass of water. I ordered the Eggplant Parmesan not in a sandwich, while my hubby ordered a calzone with an arugula salad to share. First, my Eggplant Parmesan arrived at our table in a bun, plus it was absent of sauce or mozzarella. I sent it back hoping to receive my proper order, but then received a plate of eggplant with minimal sauce on top. Maybe it's me, but Eggplant Parmesan means, sauce and cheese. Our server advised that he'd bring over some cheese (unacceptable) so I politely asked that he have it baked so the cheese melted.
I have to say that the Eggplant Parmesan was terrible. It tasted like old oil and was a far cry from what we all know as "nonna's cooking". My hubby enjoyed the calzone and the salad was decent.
I'll give this place one more chance before calling it quits on Nonna!