For many years I wanted to try Don's Lighthouse. It looked like such a "fancy" restaurant. I finally had the opportunity to go as part of a work function.
Food: My colleagues had lobster tail, and I had baked cod along with the French onion soup. Everything was good, but not great considering the prices.
Atmosphere: The dining room was nice and clean, but kind of outdated. The service was very good too.
Some other things to consider:
-They have free valet parking
-Males can not wear hats in the dining area (waitress asked male to remove his baseball hat)
-Restrooms are in the basement which is NOT ADA COMPLIANT