Overall a good experience. I'd give La Piñata 3.5 stars if half stars were possible. The supremo nachos with half machaca beef & half chicken were good and plentiful, but the chips were a little soggy. I suggest skipping the chicken as the beef had much better flavor.
We also had a combo plate with a cheese enchilada, green corn tamale, and a guacamole taco. All were good. It's way too much food for me though. The tamale and taco were great the enchilada was average mainly because the sauce was just average.
Service was good. Good atmosphere. We dined inside , but the patio looked nice with a fire.