Um, well, wow, everything is giant-sized here! Maybe its just culture shock after spending the last year in Japan and coming back on vacay, but geez, I wasn't expecting an entire watershed's worth of seafood when I ordered the fried flounder and calabash shrimp platter. I found it a bit on the bland side, but nothing the tartar sauce couldn't fix. The onion rings were also bland on the flavour front, maybe they should spice the batter they use a bit more. Fries and slaw were okay as sides, but given the H-U-G-E amount of food that I ended up with I really couldn't get too excited about it.
I couldn't manage to get dessert down at the restaurant but I got a slice of carrot cake to go and that was excellent the next day.
Three stars tentatively due to that delicious cake, and since its probably my fault for ordering fried seafood at a diner instead of actual diner food, but I'm saving my first back to the US burger for Cookout.