UPDATE******
Management reached out after reading this review and was incredibly friendly & generous, sending me a coupon to give it another try. Unfortunately, it was still not good. I will say that it was better than the first time - but the meat was still dry. The brisket had the consistency of rubber. I definitely wanted to like it more the second time around because of how great management was; the best way to describe it was "underwhelming". 2 stars for this visit.
-----------------------------------------------------
I went in around 7:30 on a Tuesday night and it was genuinely the worst meat I've ever gotten from a bbq place. The pulled pork and brisket were incredibly dry. Even drenched in BBQ sauce it was not edible (and I was starving).
The girls working were very nice and the sides (mac n chz and creamy cole slaw) were decent. It was kind of pricey ($22 for two sandwiches with two sides).
I will definitely support local bbq places from now on that have great food (Jimmys Backyard BBQ in Cuyahoga Falls is delicious and very reasonably priced). I will never be returning to Carolina BBQ.