I love, love, love NYPD Pizza. Their pizza reminds me of being on Bleecker Street in Greenwich Village enjoying a slice.
First of all, their pizza is fabulous! Rich sauce, perfectly prepared crust and fresh toppings. Plus, you can fold the slice - like you're supposed to be able to do!
Their service is hands down the best service on Mill Avenue and their beer is ice cold.
It seems like they're either really busy or really slow...I've not seen anything in between. Don't let the empty restaurant fool you. They're good at making pizza and in my opinion, have some of the best pie in Phoenix.
They're further down on Mill, so don't they don't seem to get the southern Mill traffic, but well worth the extra few block walk for lunch or dinner.
Oh, closed Sundays. Good for them!