I really really don't understand the 5 star reviews. We just went there this weekend (4/11) and although the service was wonderful, the food left so much to be desired.
First off, everything was way way too salty. It felt like they literally drenched everything in salt... so while the steak was fairly tender, the crabs came off easily from its shell, I felt like I was eating salt. The creamed corn was crunchy (not expected), the port mushroom was okay and the truffle fries was also salty.
I just think everything would've been great had everything was less salty. Save the salt please!
I did get the 75 off 150 restaurant.com gift certificate and we did tip off the original amount. Our waiter deserved it (5 stars for service!) but man, I don't know anyone would want to pay for over salted food. Maybe we should have said something.