Almost everything I've gotten here was great (along with at the Euclid store). Their menu is similar to Mr. Hero, but everything tastes fresher and seems a lot better quality. i always get mozzarella sticks and a cheesesteak. I'm a bit of a fried mozzarella connoisseur and theirs is the best Italian seasoned ones in the area.
Also recommended is the Tuesday pasta special. Currently $10.95 for 2 spaghetti/rigatoni dinners with large meatballs, garlic bread, and a salad (their House Italian dressing is really excellent too).