College Street Bar is exactly what it sounds like - a bar on College Street. There's nothing particularly spectacular about this place. It has a nice patio out back, a dark, ill-lit interior with your basic black, pseudo-swanky decor. I don't know if it's because College Street is saturated with a million bars just like it, but I never feel that this bar offers anything out of the ordinary. I've had drinks here a couple times but always to move on to bigger and better things.
Drinks are moderately priced and the bar also serves as a restaurant dishing up inexpensive Italian fare. The restaurant also appeared on Restaurant Makeover, but, in my opinion, to no avail.
College Street has tons of great restaurants and bars, but its namesake isn't one of them.