This place is a solid 4 stars.
Went for a few pints and eats, and was very satisfied with the results. Everything on the menu is under $20 (pre tax) so its at least not going to break the bank going there. In my case 2 pints, flatbread starter and sandwich main came to just over $50 including tip.
Started with the Smokey Chicken Flatbread. The first and last bite had me thinking "mmmm smokey bacon" so no complaints there as a bacon lover.
As a main, I went with the turkey club sandwich that came on awesome Ace Bakery cranberry foccacia bread. Very good and the turkey was thick cut deli style but in this case I wish the bacon was a bit more noticeable like it was on the flatbread.
Interior is nice, lots of reclaimed wood or brick walls. For some reason I felt the place still lacked identity. Maybe because aside from the nice wall surfaces, there was no art or lighting fixtures or really anything at all. Service was well intentioned, although a bit off their game in attentiveness. And I'm not sure how I feel about the name (something about Eatery reminds me of an environment similar to "Moe's Family Feedbag" from the Simpsons, but this place it far from that in reality). In the end, while I am rarely in the St Claire area - should I return I will likely come back here for my dining needs.