I am an ice cream fanatic. I have tried ice cream at many 4.5 star places with at least a thousand yelp reviews in SF and LA. But, Mitchell's is my favorite ice cream place. If this place were in foodie city like SF, I bet it would be ranked as top 3 best ice cream places. Every flavor is created to perfection, using real and fresh ingredients. The texture of ice cream is creamy and rich. I thought Mitchell's Sea Salt Caramel was better than Bi-rite in SF, because it was more creamy and less gelato-ish. Also most of my favorite flavors are seasonal and they keep me excited throughout the year.
Some of my favorite flavors are Porter Chocolate Chunk, Campfire S'more, Strawberry Rhubarb, Swiss White Chocolate, Wildberry Crumble, and Toasted Hazelnut.