I think if one is looking to fall of the diet wagon, then make the fall memorable. Benny's does that for me (as does Duck Donuts). Big slices served piping hot remind me of the many divey pizza joints sprinkled like oregano all over the Northeast.
The pizza both smelled and tasted great; it also folded nicely and crunched oh so gently when taking a bite. Mmmm . . . so good. Ingredients were fresh, prices low, and ambience just the way I like it for fresh pie: humble, divey, hipster, and cozy. I say "Give 'em a whirl!"