This restaurant is an absolute gem in an area of Madison that is otherwise altogether lacking in restaurant options. Don't be misled by the non-descript exterior or the old, faded sign. Inside, the restaurant is charming, cozy, and the food is AMAZING! Nice-sized menu with a large variety of both pizzas and pastas, including some less-common pasta selections that you don't see at any other Italian restaurants in Madison. The food is always tasty and seems fresh. I've eaten here a half dozen times and never had anything less than a 5-star experience (keeping in mind that it's not a 5-star restaurant obviously, but I nonetheless would call it a 5-star experience for what it is).