I am really struggling between giving this place a 2 or 3 stars... so consider this a 2.5.
First off the ambiance for this place is quite nice and I was surprised how well they transformed the space into a chic, dark and maybe even romantic environment. This location was used to be a scuzzy bar called "The Fan" which I used to consider my stomping grounds in my early 20's.
Our waitress was a very nice but in a sort of fake kind of way (not that I am holding that against her). She seemed to be working very hard for her tip which she earned for her attentiveness.
The menu was sort of a bit pretentious and to be honest I was bullied into the wellington county rib eye burger because I had no interest in the remainder of my options. Truth be told I made the right choice. My burger was incredible but decidedly over priced at $18.
The rest of my table had mixed reviews ranging from pretty good to the worse meal they've ever paid for. In the end, for the average price point I expected a more consistent feeling across the table. Some meals looked great and some looked sad (the elk).
Bottom line is if I was footing the bill, I would never bring someone here but if I was being treated to a meal I wouldn't necessarily drag my feet.