Went on a Friday night around 7 pm without a reservation and was told that it would be about a 45 minute wait. They directed us next door to Astor House where we could have some drinks and appetizers, so that's what we did. There, we ordered the gumbo appetizer, which turned out to be the size of a full-on entree for two. That filled us up, but after waiting for all that time for a table at Tuck Shop we were reluctant to just leave it at that, thus more eating ensued once we finally got a table.
We ordered the salmon hand pie, which was good but not great. I also wanted to try to stuffed medjool dates which I heard a lot about here on yelp, but was left disappointed. My boyfriend ordered the skirt steak which was delicious. Luckily we didn't order dessert because we got one for free when we got our check. Overall, I had higher expectations but I still enjoyed our dining experience so I might come again.