This place clearly doesn't need my recommendation, does it? Well, I'd like to particularly recommend Passage for folks who have never gotten a tattoo before.
Passage did a tattoo for me back in 2013 of a design symbolizing my middle name. I had designed it myself. Well, they did a flawless job, and three years later, I still love how it looks. Really laid-back, friendly folks here. They explained everything very clearly, walked me through the whole process, and it was just an awesome experience from start to finish.