Great service with an extensive beer selection and good pub fare. Pretty good combination, if you ask me. Plus, they have extra specials during Penguins and Pirates games, which offers some decent promotional discounts.
This place was crowded when we arrived, yet we were seated quickly and were well-attended to throughout our meal.
Not sure why this place has such negative reviews, as I'd recommend it if you're looking for pub food and beer and are in the area.
3.5 Stars...but giving it 3, since there's no half rating and it's not really worthy of 4. Cheers!