I have been here twice (when visiting Gordyville USA). Both times I had the fish. The first time I had the fish sandwich and the second time I had the fish dinner. Both times the fish was excellent.
The dinner came with the salad bar and a side. The salad bar had a nice selection. The Cole slaw was especially good I thought. The ranch dressing was home made. My cousin said the pickles were really good (I am not a pickle fan so to me it was just a pickle). I chose a baked potato for my side. there were a few draw backs, one being the butter. It was fake margarine and not real butter and the sour cream came out in a packet. I really don't like it when it's fake butter and the sour cream is in a packet.
The fish was very good. It was not greasy and had a mild flavor. Someone ordered a hamburger with grilled mushrooms on the side. Warning: the grilled mushrooms are canned mushrooms. Very generic and gross. They charged 85 cents for grilled canned mushrooms. Not cool.
So, the four star rating is basically for the atmosphere, Cole slaw and fish. Things to avoid are the grilled mushrooms & packaged sour cream.