This is the ice cream shop of my dreams. There is nothing to dislike, unless you're a stickler for authenticity -- this place opened less than a year ago, but has the ambience of an "old time soda shop."
I agree with other reviewers that said the sundaes are big enough to share. When I went, the people working were attentive and nice, but, most importantly, the ice cream was fantastic. You can't lose if you order one of the signature sundaes.