This place is amazing. I spent about 4 hours here on my last day in Montreal. The worst thing about it is that it's not in NYC :(
Everyone that works here is super friendly, especially the guy whose job it is to basically recommend, and guide you with the board games. There's a ton to choose from - from the more casual to the super nerdy, the 30 minute game to a 2+ hour marathon. Fortunately, they also have a pretty good beer selection, and some food (think sandwiches, nachos, etc). Great place to go with a small group or a friend.
Thank you Cafe Randolph for providing an option outside of the bar scene.
PS. There was a $5 cover when we went, very well worth it.