A bit overhyped in my opinion :( We went there super early because we didn't want to line up but when we got there it was pretty empty...The decor was cute with ropes hanging and there were cute, different styles of plastic captain bibs laid out on the tables. The waiters attended us quickly but the wait for the food was unexpectedly long...like 40 minutes and they got it wrong the first time.
We ordered the teriyaki fish sizzling plates because it was inexpensive around 11 dollars. It wasn't what we expected because the seafood was already on the plate when served instead of in its plastic bag. The rice was undercooked and the bottom touching the plate was overly crispy. There were many pieces of fried fish which were good but there was no sauce and they turned out to be dry. The crawfish were frustrating because although they look like mini lobsters...there was very little meat and were difficult to dissect. The clams and mussels were delicious and saucy. The shrimps were mediocre. The plate in general wasn't unified because there was barely any of the Captain Boil sauce. We chose mild spiciness but we rarely got any heat at all.
Thinking we ordered a bad item, we decided to get a 1 pound bag of mussels for 11 dollars (plus we really wanted to use our gloves and eat with our hands) with Captains Boil and medium spiciness. It was much much more delicious, hot, spicy, and saucy! There was actually alot...maybe like 20 mussels? We used some of the sauce here for the rice on the plate. My glove got pierced early on tho but using a fork didn't kill the experience.
Will probably come back but will remember to only order bags of mussels and clams !