I like Madison's for:
* larger group meals where we didn't plan far enough in advance to get a reservation elsewhere
* NFL Sunday Ticket during football seasons and brunch
* cocktails/beers when near the majestic and everywhere else is really crowded and we don't want Great Dane beers.
* their tater tots are pretty tasty
* cheese curds are greasy, but very melts/crunchy/cheesy/salty
Definitely not a go here all the time... and you are not missing anything by not coming here. But if you are, it's probably for one of the highlighted times above.