I enjoy Casey Moores for what it is -- a place for young, music-friendly, super trendy people to get together, grab drinks, smoke a ton of cigarettes, and enjoy pretty tasty bar food.
It's better than the rest of the Mill Scene (no cover, ever!) and is a pretty large establishment. No crappy club music playing all over the place, and the entire outside is a smoking patio.
Recommendations:
-Fish N Chips
-Baked Oysters (it is an oyster house after all)
-Beer specials
-Their burgers and fries are very very good.
Don't recommend:
-Calamari (it has this super heavy breading and it tastes more like an onion ring than a seafood product)
-Cold oysters on a place -- not as fresh as I'd like them, and a little grainy.