We've ordered a lot recently from Milano's Pizza - they make excellent New York style pizza and their hoagies are fantastic. Eating an italian hoagie or calzone, you can tell they are using quality meats and cheese - not your average bulk food service stuff.
There's not much space if you want to eat-in, so take-out /delivery is likely a must. You can also order online via the Slice website which adds an extra layer of convenience. This has quickly become our go-to pizza joint in the North Hills - give them a try!