I would have given five stars, but they don't accept Credit Cards - Cash and Check only.
Service at the bar was ok, he seemed a bit annoyed we didn't know straight away what we wanted and slid the beer menu towards us. Once we ordered our drinks he did smile and thank us. Saved by the smile.
There was a wait, but the restaurant was dark enough so we didn't feel like we were on a stage waiting on display. They cleared tables quickly patrons didn't seem to linger too long, perhaps because you couldn't really run up a tab here due to cash and check only. (maybe it is a good thing)
The server we had was timely, pleasant and patient. She even settled a table bet about the type of ketchup that was in the generic refillable bottle - it was Heinz! A+ in my book. However, the fries were so good, that I didn't need the ketchup.
Nachos were delicious and spicy.
My salmon BLT was tasty and FILLING. (see picture). Salmon was a big piece in delicious multigrain bread and the bacon, well, it was just perfect. Something about the midwest and their bacon. THEY DO BACON RIGHT!!!
Everyone at the table seemed to enjoy their meals as well and of course the beer. Nice selection of local craft beer!
Waitress seemed to be right there whenever we thought to look for her. Cashed us out promptly and with a smile.
If/When I return to Madison, I will definitely return.