How can you tell if a restaurant is good or not? Order the simplest thing on the menu and try it. Well my mother and I did just that and we both loved it. My father pretty much hates Italian food yet still found something that he liked. Very cool that you can pick potatoes as a side too. Not everyone loves pasta. The old Italian-American guy complaining about the long line for table was funny too.
Yelpers who ordered seafood and complained about it: Why on Earth would you order seafood in a land locked state and expect it to be fresh!? This isn't Vegas. Casinos aren't even legal here. You really think a mom & pop place in Ohio is going to pay to ship fresh seafood on dry ice?