You haven't been to Whitby until you've feasted at the Magpie Cafe, its renowned for its freshly caught fish meals, but don't just stick to the fresh cod and haddock, try the Lindisfarne oysters, sheer heaven. We generally pig out here by having lunch and dinner. The service is very friendly, well they are Yorkshire folk after all.
NB: Make sure you book first, it will save you a long wait outside on the steps.