Great food, lousy service pretty much sums up our visit. My wife and I both had the walleye on a Friday evening and it was outstanding. The fries were excellent as was the cole slaw and even the house made tartar sauce. If only the service was as good as the food.... Brittany, our server, was friendly. We just didn't see much of her! After we were seated, it took a long (!) time to order our drinks. Then it took quite awhile to get the drinks and after that, Brittany vanished. Our food was brought by someone else and we never saw Brittany again. We finished our meal and I went hunting for her just so we could pay our bill. And the restaurant was not busy at all.
Bottom line: The food is great, but it's not worth enduring the nonexistent service to get that food. There are many restaurants in Madison that offer great food AND great service!