Best. Sandwiches. Ever.
Yep, we were a bit worried that the place would feel touristy (so many reviews on Yelp! and this one is not helping!). Maybe it is the case, but honestly, who cares - even tourists are allowed to have great tastes.
We had 2 sandwiches, one hot (with more cheese that you could ever imagine, and I am French), one cold (with chicken and mango and guacamole and probably a bit of magic because it was the best thing we had in a week in Montreal). Each was around CAN$11-13. It was awesome. We didn't try desserts (they seem to mostly have pastries), I don't remember service, I just remember those sandwiches. If you are in Montreal, it would be a sin not to go eat them right now.