Amazing beer selection and at an excellent price. Great location, though it can be quite a long wait. Cheese curds are a necessity, of course. The place simply has as Wisconsin of a feel as you'll get in the state!
*Had to upgrade this to 5 stars. Idk why I haven't eaten here more often. Definitely the best in Madison and at an affordable price. The Old Fashioned House Burger may be one of the best burgers I've ever had and my bartender may have been the best I've ever seen. The man mixed up a wicked Scotch Old Fashioned w/ an Ice Sphere and knew the menu and liquor lineup like the back of his hand.