My pedicure go-to in Madison. I like coming here because it's close, it's cheap, and they do a good job. I am usually in and out within 35-45 minutes. The service is good and the color selection is vast (especially pinks and reds!). I always leave with toes that look amazing and color that lasts at least 3-4 weeks without major chips.
The only downside is that it's in a mall and people look in as they go by, which can be kind of awkward. Not a big enough deal for me not to keep coming back or recommending this place to others.