I ducked in here to grab a pizza when visiting a friend who lives in Lyndhurst. I loved it!
It's like going back in time at Tasty Pizza, and that's what I liked about it. This is a classic, "old-school", neighborhood pizza place - good people, simple menu, quality ingredients, etc. Their selection of toppings is ample and thus has something for everyone. The price was a little on the high side, but that's to be expected from a non-chain like Tasty's. Totally worth it!
The location is pretty low-key, on the end in a nondescript strip mall, with limited parking. They have a surprising amount of space, though.
I went in on a Wednesday and they had my pizza done in about 20 minutes.
I'd go back.