The owner contacted me and apologized for the not -so-good pizza I had upon my last visit. I gave this place another try....
1) last time I had my boyfriend pick up the food so I never had any interaction with the staff. This time I picked it up. The restaurant is homey. I actually felt comfortable walking in and asking for my food instead of feeling like a burden as so many places make you feel.
2) the actual food: margarita pizza was WAY better this time. More flavors all around. We finished the entire medium size in one sitting. :) We also ordered the "famous meatballs" the sauce and seasoning, again, terrific. Plus, the price isn't too bad either. An appetizer for $3.75, okay!!
I understand the other great reviews now. I'll be coming back here - next time to try the wings :)