We loved the oysters. The decor was cool and had the sea/warf like feel with a classy modern twist. The service was excellent too! We have visited Rodney's in Toronto as well and loved the oysters as well.
Since we never had a dinner in the Toronto restaurant we thought we would give it a go this time. A lot of the menu looked appealing but we settled on the dinner for two special which was a blue cod with veggies. We also chose to add a couple of scallops on top.
The fish was a whole fish, which my wife and I are not really keen on. It kind of turned her away, having this dead fish staring at you while you pick the meat off its bones. That also becomes the issue, you're picking bones out of your teeth. It was well prepared and well presented. We just wish we knew it was going to be a whole fish meal. It also really wasn't enough for two people. We left with a craving for more food. It also could have been seasoned more.
Still the oysters! You gotta go for the oysters!