GO HERE! Seriously...do yourself a favor and make the trip to Pape & Gerrard. Trust me, it's worth it.
I'm partial to the #11 on the menu (Sucuklu - Turkish pepperoni and mozzarella cheese), but they're all good. I might be a little biased because of my Turkish background, but any time I take any of my non-Turkish friends (which is a few times a year), they all LOVE it!
The owner is super nice and if you're a newbie, he'll always recommend that you try the #18 sampler, It's great because it helps you understand what your favorite is for the next time you visit...and there WILL be a next time!
Bonus: The ayran (yogurt & water savoury drink). It's definitely an aquired taste, but it goes so perfectly with your pide and worth the try.
You'll leave there with a happy, full belly and knowing you've helped to support a local business too. Win-win!