I'd only give it one if I didn't frequent here so often because of the large operable windows that make the place great to hang out and have a few beers one a nice afternoon or evening. If your only going for a lite beer on a nice evening, you can't go anywhere better.
Most of the bar staff is super, except for the one rude waitress that laughed when I asked for a Harp on St. Patrick's Day last year. "I'm not going to order a case of Harp that nobody will drink and go bad!" Last time I checked a lot of people enjoy Harp and all Guinness products especially on St. Patrick's day.
It took awhile, but the place finally has a decent beer selection (not great). I would only suggest ordering beer here because the the wine selection is terrible and the mixed drinks are the worst on the Southside. My guess is the ownership monitors the bartender's pours because they are always too weak. And by weak I mean you may as well just order a tonic water instead of an G&T because all you're going to get is tonic water. Recently they started wine night Wednesdays where you get 1/2 price bottles of wine. When I was there recently on one of these nights I asked for a wine list, which they didn't have, so I asked for a bottle of Pinot Noir. The wine was not corked or anything, but it was so bad tasting that I couldn't even finish half a glass.
The food isn't all that bad, but isn't anything special. My only advice is to avoid the fish sandwich...it made me sick one time