I wish I could review the food, but I can't because the Rusty Anchor just called and canceled our reservation for New Years Eve. It sounds like they took too many reservations and didn't realize it until the last minute.
Today is December 30th, so they get two stars -- I guess it could have been worse, they could have just turned us away when we arrived tomorrow! Still, kinda the worst night of the year to realize you took a reservation almost a month ago that you can't honor. Rusty Anchor, I direct you to Jerry Seinfeld for a lesson on the sanctity of reservations:
http://youtu.be/A7uvttu8ct0