Just had lunch there and it was delicious! I had the caprese and it was huge, I did manage to eat it all though. My friend had the quesadilla and said that was really good too. We shared the peanut butter cup cookie and both agreed it was hands down the best cookie we'd ever eaten. We also bought the crumb cake but were so full that we only took one bite each. It was good, but nothing like that cookie... I'll be returning just to buy one of those!
Cons were that it was small inside, so we sat outside. However, it is on Main street so there were a lot cars. Also, some random store two doors down pulled out some giant speakers and periodically played very loud gangster rap. Those factors did not contribute to the quaint feeling we got from Urban Picnic. I'd definitely go back again, but not sit outside!