We are frequents fliers here. In my opinion, there is NO better food and service combo in Northern Ohio. I'd go with the Filet. Also try the Meatloaf when they have it (it is based with ground filet).
Mark and the staff demonstrate perhaps the MOST important duty of a server/tender, they don't rush you! In fact, plan on spending 2 hours here. I recommend sitting at the bar and shooting the breeze with Mark, staff, or other patrons.
This is a true Hidden Gem in Northern Ohio.