I have been here three times so far. The pasties have been hit and miss for us. We tried one of the rosemary pasties and didn't really enjoy it but last time we had the pilgrim and my wife and I both thought it was great.
The pasties are smallish compared with portions at most restaurants and a little on the expensive side at 8 to 10 dollars each. The house salad comes with a great and unique dressing that is almost like a pesto. The oven chips are some of the best French fries I've had. The roasted potatoes were on the dry side. The mushy peas are good but I'm not sure what to compare them with.
The place is small and a little awkward with much of the seating being long benches. The staff is good but a little on the brusque side. Last time we were in the waiter told us he had something else take care of and asked if we minded waiting. He was trying to get another table out that needed to get back to work. Once we had his attention he was very attentive that left me feeling like we were bothering him at the same time.
Neither my wife nor I really care for the red wine gravy. It tastes a little muddy to us. The potato leek soup is excellent with a strong flavor of stilton cheese and a nice slice of bread. They also have a great beer selection.
I'm sure we will go back again but Cornish Pasty is not on our regular rotation.