Overall it was a good experience. The service was friendly, the restaurant was clean with plenty of space and you don't feel crammed in at all like some restaurants these days. It's especially good because the old restaurant in this spot had tiny booths. Butchie's has nice spacious tables.
As for the food it was good. I ordered the "Meat + 1" which for me was a burger and fries. The fries are GREAT honestly the 2nd best fries I've had in all of Durham Region. The burger was good. They use some sort of spice in the meat which gives it a bold flavor which I wasn't a huge fan of. I'm more of a just the meat alone kind of guy but it was fine. The only thing was it seemed a tad overdone. I know you can't get medium rare burger in Canada but it seemed more well done that most. Fresh ingredients though. Bacon and cheese were really good. If I had one concern is that the drink is quite small. A fountain soda is $2.25 and it's the size of a can of pop but with ice in it. Since the food is freshly made it take awhile so you are almost done your drink by the time the food gets there.
I'll definitely go back to Butchie's in the near future I'll just have one of the other items on the menu with those tasty fries.