We almost didn't find this place as their address is 5th Avenue, but they are really in Market Square. Head upstairs to a very noisy environment. We both started off with a beer. Mine was Firehouse Red and my husband had some IPA. We both made good choices. Server was quick and helpful.
I LOVE buffalo chicken, so the Buffy the Mac Attack Slayer was a no brainer for me. My husband ordered the Full Monte Cristo. Food came quickly and was served with their tomato soup and chips. Everything was hot and seemed freshly made. The soup is nothing special, or even really like tomato soup. I used it as a dip for my chips. I was super disappointed in my sandwich. I love mac and cheese, but that's all you all you could taste. The buffalo chicken had no zip to it and just tasted like cooked chicken. Really a big bummer as this combo was a dream come true for me. My husband really liked his sandwich. His was huge and although different, as it wasn't fried in egg batter, he loved the flavors.
Prices were typical of a restaurant of this type. Variety of beer is nice, daily specials look priced well.