This place came highly recommended to me, even though I'm not a beer drinker. I was looking for comfort food and a comfortable environment at the end of a long day on a business trip. This place delivered.
I had the macaroni and cheese with Amish chicken. It was delicious - creamy and tasted homemade. My server was attentive and confirmed that the Amish chicken was in fact raised on an Amish farm - free range, etc.
It's a little overpriced (hence 4 stars instead of 5), but otherwise a great place to visit.