The ice cream is great, and therefore it deserves a 3.5-4 the taste and its creamy, and they have awesome selection.
Ive seen more epic ice cream, but then again, I get around a lot. When I used to live around here, it was a pretty common spot for people to have ice cream, and at the end of the day, the ice cream doesn't let you down.
I do feel like the space could offer more. Its a little "empty' besides the ice cream. Not that I expect food, but it would be cool if they threw crepes into the mix, or like more unique specialty coffees. But the st clair area isn't doing too well. So I guess you can't blame a local mom and pop shop.