This is pretty much the only place in town you can get a seafood boil. I've had the best of the best in the south and this is probably as good as it will get for Madison. Don't expect fresh seafood because well it's Wisconsin! I thought the prices were kind of expensive, especially if you want to add extra corn or potatoes.
I went when they first opened and ordered a pound of blue crab and crawfish with the Cajun sauce/spicy and it was delicious. I went again a few weeks later and when I tried to order the same thing again the waitress kindly told me that their Cajun option was now a dry rub instead of sauce. The only seafood boil I'll eat is if it's nice and saucy so I was disappointed they changed it to a dry rub. The 3rd time I went they changed it back to a sauce instead of dry rub (:
I would recommend this to anyone who is a fan of seafood boils.