I've been to Mac's, Bill Spoon's, the other Mac's, Queen City Q and then decided to check out City Smoke about a year after it opened.
I'm strictly making my judgement on the mac & cheese and fries because, well, thats whats important to me. Unfortunately, they didn't win me over. The mac & cheese wasn't cheesy & creamy enough for my liking and the fries had a bit too much seasoning.
I think I'll stick to Queen City Q when I'm looking for BBQ uptown.